WHOOP just drew a line in the sand.
And, the decentralized health battle just escalated.
Last month, the FDA issued a warning letter over its Blood Pressure Insights feature, arguing the wearable had crossed into unapproved medical-device territory.
This month, WHOOP responded.
They’re not backing down.
CEO Will Ahmed put it plainly: “We do not plan on removing the feature from our app. The law is on our side.”
This isn’t just a regulatory disagreement.
It’s a power struggle over the future of health.
Here’s what really happening:
The FDA is flexing authority over trend-based, non-diagnostic wellness features.
WHOOP is invoking the 21st Century Cures Act, which protects wellness tools that don’t diagnose or treat disease, to defend BPI.
Both sides are citing “safety”.
But underneath it all, a deeper battle is brewing:
Decentralized, data-driven, prevention-first, consumer-led health
vs.
Centralized, top-down, disease-centric sick-care built around regulation and control
And, make no mistake — this is all about who sets the rules of the game.
And, that battle is now public.
Intended use ≠ perceived use: If your tool feels clinical, even with disclaimers, you may get treated like a medical device by regulators.
FDA’s stance is evolving: The FDA previously allowed both general wellness and clinical-grade versions of tools like heart rate monitors. But, the line is blurring. Blood Pressure Insights feels diagnostic. Even with disclaimers, if it looks clinical, they’ll treat it like a device.
The ecosystem: Founders, investors, clinicians, and policymakers are all watching closely. The precedent set here will ripple across wearables, wellness AI, and beyond.
If WHOOP is forced to remove the feature, the chilling effect will ripple across health tech.
If WHOOP wins, it reinforces and strengthens the legitimacy of a decentralized, data-informed, prevention-first, proactive wellness model, and forces regulators to modernize.
We need:
Clearer legal language around intended use
Open-source frameworks for ethical wellness AI
Proactive coalition-building across founders, investors, clinicians, and policymakers
Radical consumer-first transparency so that users understand what data can/cannot do
The FDA must evolve with the industry, not against it.
And, WHOOP is forcing that conversation into the open.
As decentralized wellness gains market share, the system moves to regulate, restrict, and reclaim control, often under the banner of “safety”.
Sometimes that’s valid.
But, sometimes, it’s protectionism in disguise.
The future of health is:
Decentralized. Data-informed. Prevention first.
We will either shape it together or watch it get regulated out of existence.
Where should the line be drawn between prevention-first insights and regulated diagnostics—and who should get to draw it? What do you think? Let me know in the comments.
And, if you have any other questions or comments, don’t hesitate to ask me any time in my weekly Q&A in my paid subscriber channel. If you’re not a paid subscriber, sign up below.
If you found this helpful or thought-provoking and want to support my writing, here’s how you can help:
Tap the heart so that I know it resonated
Leave a thoughtful comment—I read and appreciate every one!
Forward to a friend who might need to hear it
Share it with your community on Substack Notes, Instagram (tag @meghanswidler), or LinkedIn (and tag me there too!)
Upgrade to a paid subscription below to support deeper work like this
Your support helps me continue creating content that empowers, educates, and liberates. I appreciate it more than you know.
Ready to cleanse your body, transform your health, and upgrade your life?
Take my free Detox Phase Quiz to uncover your physical symptoms you’re currently experiencing and to find out where to start your cleansing journey based on your body’s current needs.
Then, explore The Cleanses — a series of powerful digital cleanses that will guide you through a transformative detox journey towards optimal health and vitality, step by step. Whether you’re a total beginner or feel ready for deeper cleansing, these programs are designed to help you feel like your radiant, vibrant self again.
If you’re ready for a deeply personalized, high-touch experience, I currently have 2-3 spots open for new VIP coaching clients. This is for you if you want a highly customized plan, 1:1 support and guidance, and real accountability to help you heal on every level—physically, mentally, emotionally, spiritually, and energetically. Want to know what it’s like to work with me? Read 50+ client testimonials and see for yourself. I’d love to connect with you.
Would you prefer to connect in person? I’d love to meet you. Come watch me speak at Eudemonia Summit this coming November 13–16. Reserve your spot below, and use code MEGHAN50 for $50 off.